Dramatic GE engine explosion on Boeing 767 poses puzzle for investigators

14 Nov 22:32 | Comments (7)


Industry experts say the cause of the incident was the first of its kind. 

The nearly catastrophic explosion of an engine that caused a fire on an American Airlines Boeing 767 just short of takeoff in Chicago on Oct. 28 occurred when a specific part that had never before failed broke into pieces. 

The breakup of a heavy metal disk that rotates in the engine core reveals a new risk to airline passengers that, however rare, has already spurred a scramble by engine-maker General Electric and government safety agencies to find and fix the vulnerability."The risk will be eliminated," said John Goglia, a former National Transportation Safety Board member with more than 40 years' experience in the aviation-safety industry. "Will it be eliminated before the next one? That's the real question. Everything relies upon the timeliness of the system to correct itself." 

American Airlines Flight 383 to Miami was speeding down the runway at O'Hare International Airport in Chicago when the second-stage disk of the high-pressure turbine broke apart inside the right engine with a loud explosion that blew metal shrapnel out through the engine casing. 

Hot metal ripped through the wing, igniting aviation fuel. In an update this month, the National Safety Board, often called the NTSB, described how the pilot aborted the takeoff just seconds before reaching a speed at which he would have had to leave the ground. Slamming on the brakes as the jet reached a speed of 154 miles per hour, he brought the plane to a halt within 25 seconds and 900 yards further down the runway. 

Moving quickly, the cabin staff evacuated all 161 passengers and nine crew using the escape slides on the undamaged left side of the aircraft. Twenty people suffered minor injuries. 

Behind them on the runway, the black smoke billowing skyward and the blaze melting the right wing into a drooping mess testified to how close the passengers had come to a large-scale tragedy. 

GE spokesman Rick Kennedy stresses the reliability of the CF6 engine involved. The latest models, introduced in the 1980s, currently power about 4,000 widebody jets, including Boeing 767s, 747s and Airbus A330s, and have flown for more than 220 million hours. 

"The CF6 is the workhorse engine of jumbo jets on a level never experienced before," Kennedy said. 

Yet the danger posed by a so-called "uncontained engine failure" cannot be overstated. The disk that broke apart in Chicago — one of two disks in what's called the highpressure turbine that drives the engine's air compressor — is about 2 feet in diameter and weighs more than 100 pounds. 

At full power for takeoff, the temperature in the high-pressure turbine reaches more than 2,200 degrees. 

The pod around the engine has Kevlar armor around the big fan at the front, designed to contain any blades that fly off. But the pod cannot possibly contain the enormous energy of flying metal ejected from an engine-core breakup. 

The NTSB has said one piece of the broken disk went through the right wing, then arced high over the airplane and came crashing through the roof of a UPS warehouse almost 1,000 yards away. 

"Any time a turbine disk fails, it's a big deal," Goglia said. 

In 2006, a CF6-80 engine — the same model as in the Chicago incident — on another American Airlines 767 that was powered up during maintenance, exploded on the ground in Los Angeles, with no passengers aboard. 

A big piece of the high-pressure turbine disk in the left engine pierced the engine casing, sliced through the airplane's lower fuselage and embedded itself like an ax-head in the casing of the right engine on the other side of the airplane. 

That jarring incident came after two other CF6-80 high-pressure turbine-disk breakups. 

In 2000, as a US Airways 767 was undergoing engine maintenance on the ground in Philadelphia, a disk rupture split the left engine clean in two and ignited a fire under the wing. 

In 2002, it happened while a jet was in the air. 

The left engine of an Air New Zealand 767 blew up six minutes after takeoff from Brisbane, Australia, damaging the wing flaps and forcing an emergency landing. Luckily, there was no fire that time, and all 200 people on board were safe. 

In all three of those CF6- 80 incidents, the disk that broke up was the first of two inside the turbine

Although the two disks look alike, the first stage is next to the hottest part of the engine core and must withstand the highest temperatures and air pressure. 

After the 2006 incident, the government safety system kicked into high gear. The Federal Aviation Administration, or FAA, issued an Airworthiness Directive ordering urgent inspections of these disks inside older CF6-80 engines. 

Subsequently, GE redesigned the first-stage disk to take more stress, adjusting the shape and the composition of the sophisticated nickel alloy. 

All planes flying today have been retrofitted with that redesigned disk, Kennedy said. 

"That's behind us," he said. 

But the disk that exploded in Chicago was the second-stage disk

This disk is subject to lower temperatures and air flow, so it undergoes relatively less stress than the first. 

"There has never been an Airworthiness Directive associated with a secondstage disk," Kennedy said. "This is new." 

That's what's raised alarm bells at the NTSB and the FAA. The NTSB said that particular disk had been flying for 18 years and completed almost 11,000 flights, short of the limit of 15,000 cycles after which it must be replaced. 

Goglia and other industry experts said the sudden breakup almost certainly stemmed from a microscopic crack, caused by a flaw in the metal invisible to the eye, that grew over years of service. 

Using electron microscopes, metallurgists at the NTSB Materials Laboratory in Washington, D.C., are now scanning the pieces of the broken stage-two disk, 95 percent of which was recovered. 

"They'll examine the  metal down to the tiniest element to determine the cause," said Goglia. 


Please login to do comment.